PR Forum

Outtakes & Special Appearances, 1999-2012
A CS production, February 2014

1. Dirt Road Blues - outtake, Masked & Anonymous Session, 2002
2. The Times They Are A-Changin' - The White House 2010
3. Tell Ol' Bill - outtake, North Country Session, 2005
4. Things Have Changed - The Oscars 2001
5. Maggie's Farm - The Grammys 2011
6. It Takes A Lot To Laugh, It Takes A Train To Cry - with the Wynton Marsalis Band 2004
7. Standing In The Doorway - outtake, Masked & Anonymous session 2002
8. A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall - Expo Zaragoza session 2008
9. Cry A While - The Grammys 2002
10. Watching The River Flow - Amazon.com 10th Birthday session 2005
11. A Change Is Gonna Come - The Apollo 2004
12. Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues - Rio 2008
13. Don't Think Twice, It's Alright - with the Wynton Marsalis Band 2004
14. Blind Willie McTell - Critic's Choice Awards 2012
15. I'll Remember You - outtake, Masked & Anonymous Session 2002
16. Bottleneck Polka - Dharma & Greg session 1999
Bonus track:
17. Things Have Changed - 2009 AFI Tribute

This set collects the best of Bob Dylan's unreleased outtakes, sessions, and special appearances from 1999 to 2012.

For a brief introduction to the tracks:

Dirt Road Blues - This is one of the only two performances of this, which both occurred during the Masked and Anonymous sessions. They are likely two portions of the same performance, but this one is more complete and lacks any dropouts or movie dialogue. Unfortunately, it also lacks lyrics. The instrumentation offers a good introduction to the CD, however, so it is present here.

The Times They Are A-Changin' - My personal favorite of the CD. At an event celebrating the progress of Civil Rights in America, Dylan gave one of the great appearances of his career. Virtually every word is heartbreaking, as all of the broken and fulfilled promises of the 1960s come to the surface of this brief performance. The piano sounds like raindrops, and the bass deftly weaves through the song. This is Bob Dylan at the top of his game.

Tell Ol' Bill #3 - This is a radically altered, slow blues outtake of Tell Ol' Bill, which appeared on the North Country soundtrack and Dylan's own Bootleg Series Volume 8. Frankly, this is my favorite of the three, with soulful vocals pouring everything they've got into each line, along with a beautiful instrumental break at the end of the song.

Things Have Changed - Bob Dylan performed this at the 2001 Oscars, and though a verse has been excised, it is pretty faithful to the studio version. The audio here is an improvement on the version present on the Hollow Horn "Some Big TV Network" collection, with more space in the recording.

Maggie's Farm - This is a contentious performance from the 2011 Grammys. The mix is truly lacking for the first verse, but a ragged passion pervades the rest of the recording. The accordion and backing vocals really lend a unique character to this track.

It Takes A Lot To Laugh, It Takes A Train To Cry - Here is one of the highlights of the collection, recorded at a benefit event with the Wynton Marsalis band. It's a jazz take, complete with horns. This remastering was carried out by Crystal Cat for their Rochester '04 record, and is an improvement on the other circulating track.

Standing in the Doorway - I am proud of the splicing present here. The outtake remained full of movie ambience and dialogue, which has been carefully removed to present as complete a recording as possible. The vocals are extraordinary, though not as strong as the live renditions that would be performed in 2004. We can only hope a full version surfaces someday.

A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall - The song was recorded for a water benefit in 2008. Dylan and his touring band created a mid-tempo, shuffle arrangement of the poetic classic. It's not the best rendition, but the organ shines out here as a driving force. The final fade is abrupt, due to the nature of the original recording, but you get to here a Theme Time-era announcement of the singer's support for the mission to make water pure.

Cry A While - We move into much bluesier territory here, with a scathing performance of a song from the "Love and Theft" LP. It hews close to other performances of the tune from 2002, but the recording is very high quality. Unfortunately, there are serious signal issues at the end, which were present on all files I could find. I've minimized the intrusiveness through editing, but it could not be removed entirely. Regardless, it barely detracts from the outstanding song.

Watching the River Flow - Admittedly, the audio on this recording is of a slightly lower quality than other tracks on this compilation, as it came from a streaming broadcast on Amazon.com's website. Still, the stream was fairly high quality and the difference is not especially noticeable. The song itself is one of the best renditions of this tune, which first appeared on Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits Volume II. Of particular interest is the arrangement's startling similarity to Spirit on the Water, which would be released the following year.

A Change is Gonna Come - Wow, what can be said about this. The vocals are transcendant, and the significance of the song, a civil rights ballad inspired by Dylan's own "Blowin' in the Wind" is clear. The audio here is superior to that present on Genuine Bootleg Series 4.

Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues - If you hate the organ sound, you may hate this song. It is simply an excerpt from Bob Dylan's stop in Rio duringhis 2008 tour, but his enthusiasm and the soundboard quality recording make this worthy of inclusion. An excellent TV clip of the performance is available, and I recommend seeking it out.

Don't Think Twice, It's Alright - Here is the second and final track from Dylan's collaboration with the Wynton Marsalis band. It's a very odd arrangement, and completely unique. Even though the vocals are a bit buried, it's worth the download for this track alone.

Blind Willie McTell - This one of the gems of the collection. Bob Dylan pulled out all the stops to deliver a powerful performance of this classic American tale. He breathes new life into the already moving song, and the last verse in particular is a stunning tribute to the lasting power of Dylan's poetry.

I'll Remember You - Here is another outtake from the Masked and Anonymous sessions, and certainly the best of the three. It offers a full acoustic rearrangement of the Empire Burlesque song, and is heads above the original album take. The vocals are spellbinding. I was unable to fully remove the interfering audio from the beginning of the song, but minimized its presence through volume adjustment. It fades out rapidly, and the listener is left to hear the singer's testimony.

Bottleneck Polka - This is an amusing little ditty from Bob Dylan's appearance on Dharma & Greg in 1999, leading a band which included T-Bone Burnett! It's a fitting counterpoint to the disc's opener, "Dirt Road Blues," and a fine way to bring this compilation full-circle.

The 2009 AFI Tribute performance of "Things Have Changed" is featured as a bonus track. It does not appear as a primary song in the set, since it would have been a duplicate. Feel free to add it at the end if loaded onto an iPod or burned onto disc, since there is space.

I have not reduced the audio fidelity of those recordings, and all tracks here are offered in the best quality available.

Thank you Robert